Thanksgiving Cookie Boxes

Thanksgiving preorder pickup: Wednesday, November 25, 2026, from 9 AM to 6 PM at the Cookie Paradise trailer in the Holiday Center parking lot, 3950 25th St., Columbus, IN 47203.

Need a different pickup date or time? Enter your request in Pickup notes on the Thanksgiving preorder page so we can confirm it with you.

Skip the baking and bring dessert to Thanksgiving. Each Cookie Paradise box has four flavors: Maple Pecan, Sugar Cream, Carrot Cake, and Chocolate Chip.

• 8-cookie box: 2 cookies of each flavor.
• 12-cookie box: 3 cookies of each flavor.

Handmade in Columbus, Indiana.