8-cookie box
2 cookies of each flavor
Maple Pecan · Sugar Cream · Carrot Cake · Chocolate Chip
$25.00 per box
Thanksgiving Cookie Boxes
Thanksgiving preorders
Skip the baking. Bring the cookies.
Take dessert off your Thanksgiving to-do list. Both boxes come with the same four flavors, ready to share at the table.
Preorder pickup · Wednesday, November 25, 2026
9 AM to 6 PM at the Cookie Paradise trailer
Holiday Center parking lot, 3950 25th St., Columbus, IN 47203
Preorder your cookie box
Need a different pickup date or time? Fill in Pickup notes for your box before adding it to your order.
12-cookie box
3 cookies of each flavor
Maple Pecan · Sugar Cream · Carrot Cake · Chocolate Chip
$35.00 per box